October 29, 2026
"It's a pretty long list, and a level of intensity for the East End that's kind of unusual," Celine Valensie told Southforker in June. She was describing the state contract behind the new Lighthouse Cafe at Montauk Point. The contract sets the opening hour, 10 a.m., and requires the cafe to open daily. It also names the point when the cafe may close for the season, which is Thanksgiving.
Montauk's summer is often said to end on Labor Day, but the Point keeps a later schedule. The cafe's contract runs to Thanksgiving. The lighthouse grounds close after Saturday, November 28. That same Saturday evening, the lighthouse is lit to start the holidays. One season closes and the next opens at the same address on the same weekend. This year, the winter that follows is also the first since 1963 without Herb's Market.
The Lighthouse Cafe opened June 4 in the former Lighthouse Grill space next to Montauk Point Lighthouse. It is run by Celine Valensie and Sean McPherson, the business partners behind Crow's Nest. As Southforker reported, the pair lost the state bid three years in a row. They were offered the contract this spring after the winning bidder dropped out.
The setup is a counter-service concession: you order at the counter and wait for a buzzer. The opening menu included pastries, quiches, lamb merguez, a croque monsieur, and a lobster salad among seven salads, plus cocktails, wine by the glass, and coffee. The lighthouse can draw up to 250,000 visitors a year, according to the same report. Valensie described this first year as a chance to "collect some data points."
That visitor count explains why the closing date is fixed. A concession built for a quarter of a million visitors a year has little reason to stay open once the grounds close. The contract ties the cafe's season to the same Thanksgiving weekend that ends the lighthouse's own season. If you have been meaning to try it, the weeks before the holiday are this year's chance.
Most of Montauk's season-turning happens over these four days. All of the events below are free.
The Turkey Trot's history ties the weekend back to the Point. On Thanksgiving morning in 1976, John Keeshan and some friends ran from the Village Green to the Lighthouse and back. The run grew into an annual tradition that the East Hampton Town Recreation Department now directs. For the 50th running, that original 11-mile out-and-back is virtual only. The in-person race stays on the shorter courses. The Montauk Sun event page lists the day as 8 a.m. to 5 p.m., but the start time is 10 a.m.
Thursday morning starts at the Circle with a race that once ran to the lighthouse. Saturday evening ends at the lighthouse itself, and the grounds close behind it.
The weekend's rituals are the ones Montauk has kept for decades. The winter after it is missing something it has had since 1963.
27east reported this summer that Herb's Market, the grocery and deli, would close at the end of September. The store had announced the news on Instagram: "After so many years of being a part of the Montauk community, our time is coming to an end at the end of September." Herb's opened in 1963, and Joe Ferraro bought the business in 2012.
Spark Hamptons noted in mid-October that Harold "Herb" Herbert founded the store at 778 Montauk Highway. Its fried chicken, sandwiches, and butcher counter made it a gathering place for generations of Montauk residents and visitors. Spark also reported that the Ferraro family planned to sell the equipment and fixtures and that no replacement business had been announced. In August, News 12 described Herb's as Montauk's oldest grocery store.
With Herb's gone, Montauk heads into the off-season with one fewer year-round place to buy groceries and deli food on Montauk Highway.
The best guide to Montauk's winter food options is still Visit Montauk's "What's Open in Montauk This Winter." It is dated January 26, 2026, so it describes last winter and comes with the Chamber's own warning that hours vary and you should call ahead. Its sit-down roster named Montes at the Manor, Shagwong Tavern, The Bird, Inlet Seafood, The Point Bar and Grill, Muse at the End, Tauk at Trails End, 668 The Gig Shack, John's Drive-In, John's Pancake House, Naturally Good Foods & Cafe, Harvest on Fort Pond, and Gigi's at Gurney's. Marlena's Packout was listed for drinks only. The grab-and-go list named Fierro's Pizza, Hampton Coffee Co., M&R Deli, Pizza Village, and Tony's Meat Market.
Several places have posted hours or added service for this fall and winter:
The business sites don't date their posted hours, and last winter's Chamber list advised calling ahead. Do the same before you head out on a cold Tuesday.
A few dates sit on either side of the holiday. Before Thanksgiving, Montauk Manor at 236 Edgemere Street hosts a murder-mystery weekend November 6 through 8. Its listing gives a starting price of $760 per person, double occupancy. That is also the last stretch of the year to visit the Lighthouse Cafe while it is still open.
After the lighting, the season moves from the Point back to the center of the hamlet. The Montauk Chamber of Commerce and Visit Montauk list the fifth annual Magic of Montauk Holiday Fair on the Town Green for December 12. The fair includes a lit holiday path, vendors, a cocoa contest, children's activities, food trucks, live music, Santa, and live reindeer. Another calendar lists the fair as December 12 and 13, so check the Chamber's listing before you plan around a second day. The lighthouse gift shop keeps weekend hours, weather permitting, through December 20.
If this is your first winter in Montauk and you want to know how the hamlet runs once the lighthouse grounds close for the year, I'm always happy to talk it through. With roots on the East End going back twelve generations, Jeanne Hutson knows the off-season calendar as well as the summer one. Let's Connect.
Stay up to date on the latest real estate trends.
November 19, 2026
November 12, 2026
November 5, 2026
October 29, 2026
October 22, 2026
October 15, 2026
A licensed Realtor® with extensive hometown knowledge of the East End villages and hamlets