What's Next for the Lights, Trees, and Sidewalks on Amagansett's Main Street?

November 5, 2026

Silver cedar shingles and a white clapboard cottage porch above a brick landing, with autumn oakleaf hydrangea beside the steps.

Two years ago, the plan to light Amagansett's Main Street called for about 50 fixtures between Windmill Lane and Meeting House Lane. As of late October, the drawings showed 74 lights running all the way to the train station. At the October 26 forum in the Amagansett School gym, few people said they wanted the street to stay dark. The objection was to lighting every stretch the same way. 27east reported that the plan is "floating adrift," and that the town is unlikely to push it forward quickly without consensus.

The people who spoke up know Main Street as a run of different places, from shops and old houses to the library, a farm market, the school, and the station. Over two years the plan has grown longer and more uniform, and the October forum showed how little support that version has.

How 50 lights became 74

The project started with the Amagansett Citizens Advisory Committee, which began raising concerns about dark stretches of Main Street about seven years ago. By December 2022, The East Hampton Star reported that the effort had stalled. People were still debating how much community support it had and who would pay for an engineering study. The town supervisor wanted the roughly 1,500 property owners in the hamlet's lighting district informed before any money was spent.

From there, the plan has been redrawn several times:

When reported Fixtures Stretch Estimated cost
November 2024 About 50, 12 feet tall, roughly 100 feet apart Windmill Lane to Meeting House Lane $1.3 million
November 2025 46 to 50, with possible bollards from Meeting House Lane toward the firehouse Windmill Lane to Meeting House Lane Not reported
Summer 2026 64 Not specified $1.7 million
October 2026 74 West of Windmill Lane to the train station No estimate yet

The early version was modest and fairly carefully designed. The Star's November 2024 account described globeless LED fixtures at 2,700K pointing downward. The existing cobra-head lights on metal poles would be removed, some lights on utility poles would stay, and no trees would be disturbed. By the time of the Star's notice for the October forum, the study area reached from Indian Wells Highway at the west end to the junction at Abram's Landing Road in the east. The town's consultant, L.K. McLean Associates, was working on Dark Sky-compliant designs that meet New York State Department of Transportation rules, using fixtures under 12 feet tall and keeping impact on trees to a minimum.

The plan presented to the advisory committee in July aimed to start work in 2027, pending review by the town's Architectural Review Board and comments from local groups. Since then the fixture count has gone up, though Councilman Tom Flight, the town's liaison to Amagansett, told 27east he doubts the 74-light version will happen as drawn.

The cost falls only on the lighting district. 27east reported that under the $1.7 million plan, the owner of a house valued at $1.25 million would pay $20.28 more on their tax bill. No figure exists yet for the 74-light version.

One street, several kinds of street

At the forum, 27east reported, Flight put the main worry plainly: "There's real concern that having 70 identical fixtures would make it look like an airport runway and just feel too homogenous."

Amagansett Library Board President Barbara Hill described the alternative. "The board believes that the lighting should be designed with sensitivity to the ebbs and flows along Main Street," she said, according to 27east. "There's commercial, entertainment, historic, residential, civic and agricultural areas, and they should not be lit the same." The library board had already said much the same in an August letter to the Town Board. That letter called for "a more comprehensive evaluation of the necessity, efficacy, and historic appropriateness of lighting changes," including in the northernmost parking field of the municipal lot.

Hill's list matches the street as it stands. The stretch near Amagansett Square has its shops and cafes. The Sea Dragon Books storefront, which opened in June at the entrance to the business district, sits near houses that predate any streetlight. Farther along, Amber Waves Farm keeps its market at 367 Main Street. Then come the school and the walk to the station.

Flight has shown some openness to this. He told 27east he would consider low bollard lights from the school to the train station, where a light below eye level might fit better. He also agreed that some western stretches may not need fixtures at all. The town's planners, by contrast, have called for the same fixtures throughout.

The fixture design drew pointed comments too. Dan Mongan, a trustee of the Amagansett Historical Association, has argued that Main Street looks much the same as it did in the earliest photographs of the hamlet. "The published plan recommends replicas of 19th-century Manhattan street lamps," he said at the forum, as 27east reported. "Placing a fake urban fixture in front of our authentic, historic, rural property is not a public benefit." Amagansett Village Improvement Society President Victor Gelb compared the design to a template. To him, it looked like the engineers had taken their plans for Sag Harbor and Montauk's Main Street and "plopped it down on Amagansett." Gelb was careful to say that AVIS is "not opposed to improved lighting along Main Street," only to this design.

27east noted that real antique fixtures aren't practical for the town to install. That likely narrows the choice to plain contemporary designs.

What lies under the street

The lighting plan and the sidewalk proposal both touch the canopy of old trees along Main Street. At the forum, much of the worry centered on the underground trenching the lighting would need.

"We have this beautiful canopy of trees all the way along Main Street," Gelb said, according to 27east. "How does trenching for underground power affect the health of those trees? And what guarantees are there that those trees will survive? Most of them, over 100 years old, survived the 1938 hurricane." Flight said the engineers have strict instructions not to damage, remove, or disturb any trees. Local arborists still worry that the trenches could cut straight through the root systems.

At the forum, the sidewalks often came up ahead of the lights. Residents asked why lighting was getting priority over cracked, uneven pavement. Hill suggested doing both projects at once. Flight said he would work with the Highway Department on sidewalk repairs in the meantime.

A separate sidewalk proposal is already on the table. In March, The Star reported on a Town Board discussion about the south side of Main Street from Hedges Lane to the west entrance of Amagansett Square. Councilman David Lys described replacing the four-foot walk with a five-foot walk where possible, so summer walkers can go side by side and stop wearing down the grass strip. The plan would set brick in concrete between the trees, with the big old trees boxed into six-by-six-foot planters to match the north side of the street. Lys said the brick-in-concrete method lasts longer, resists heaving into tripping hazards, and makes snow removal easier. Board members were supportive, and the plan also drew some critical public comment.

Safety, the reason the lighting plan started, looks different depending on who is asked. Pedestrian visibility for drivers was the original case for new lights. East Hampton Town Police, however, have pointed to the traffic friction and drop-off hazards from rideshare services as a more pressing safety problem than dim lighting.

What has to happen before a pole goes in

Amagansett's Main Street is also a state highway, and a town consultant told The Star in November 2025 that this is why the project has moved slowly. According to 27east, the remaining steps are:

  1. A Town Board environmental review under SEQRA.
  2. Submission of the project to the New York State Department of Transportation.
  3. Approval from the town's Architectural Review Board.
  4. A public hearing.

Groundwork has been underway for a year. Advisory committee minutes from October 20, 2025, posted on the Town of East Hampton's agenda center, record that DOT as-built drawings had arrived and base maps were in progress. PSEG was working on power-connection layouts, and the committee planned to ask for feedback from AVIS and the Historical Association. Fixture count, cost, and the street's full extent can all still change, and 27east noted the plan could also be dropped entirely.

Anyone in the lighting district who wants a say will have chances at the Architectural Review Board and the public hearing. In the meantime, Flight plans to work with the Highway Department on sidewalk repairs.

I follow questions like this one with a preservationist's interest, because the street in front of an old Amagansett house is part of its character. If you'd like to talk about how a historic home relates to the Main Street around it, Jeanne Hutson is glad to hear from you. Let's Connect.

Connect With Jeanne

A licensed Realtor® with extensive hometown knowledge of the East End villages and hamlets