November 19, 2026
On March 17, the oceanfront house at 115 Beach Lane closed at $59 million, 27east reported. Barnes Coy Architects designed it as a pavilion-style house in 2018, and HBO viewers know it as Josh Aaronson's home in "Succession." At that point it was the second-largest sale on the East End this year, after Dune Cottage at 43 East Dune Lane in East Hampton, which sold for $72 million on March 6. Two days later, 176 Sayre's Path closed at $9,095,000, according to the East Hampton Star's deed column.
Between January and October 2026, the Star and 27east deed columns recorded fifteen Wainscott closings. Those two March sales make up more than 60 percent of the combined value, about $68.1 million of roughly $108.3 million. The other thirteen tell you what a home in this hamlet costs. They ran from $1.475 million to $5.45 million, and the middle of that range is near $3 million. If you are comparing Wainscott with its neighbors, use the deed list and not the average.
The list below covers recorded Wainscott sales with closing dates from January 16 through October 8, 2026. It doesn't include every sale.
| Address | Price | Closing date | Reported in |
|---|---|---|---|
| 4 South Breeze Drive | $1,475,000 | Aug. 21 | 27east |
| 11 Oakwood Court | $1,600,000 | Aug. 24 | 27east |
| 28 Ridge Road | $1,995,000 | April 20 | East Hampton Star |
| 95 Sayre's Path | $2,250,000 | Jan. 23 | East Hampton Star |
| 26 Goodfriend Drive | $2,600,000 | Jan. 16 | 27east |
| 55 West Gate Road | $2,600,000 | Feb. 5 | East Hampton Star |
| 179 Sayre's Path | $3,010,000 | Jan. 16 | East Hampton Star |
| 19 Georgica Woods Lane | $3,175,000 | April 20 | East Hampton Star |
| 31 East Gate Road | $3,350,000 | May 15 | East Hampton Star |
| 3 Whitney Lane | $3,580,000 | July 29 | 27east |
| 17 Elishas Path | $4,000,000 | June 17 | 27east |
| 1 Fernwood Road | $5,100,000 | Jan. 28 | East Hampton Star |
| 89 Wainscott Main Street | $5,450,000 | Oct. 8 | East Hampton Star |
| 176 Sayre's Path | $9,095,000 | March 19 | East Hampton Star |
| 115 Beach Lane | $59,000,000 | March 17 | 27east |
Some of these sales appeared in print months after closing. The Goodfriend Drive sale closed January 16 and showed up in a 27east deed table in late October, so a fall deed column can still be reporting winter closings. In a hamlet this small, a few late filings can change a year-to-date picture.
Across all fifteen closings from January through October 2026, the average price comes to about $7.2 million. Without 115 Beach Lane, the average for the other fourteen falls to about $3.5 million. That is half the figure, from removing one house. Take out 176 Sayre's Path as well, and the thirteen remaining sales average about $3.1 million.
The median barely changes through any of this. With all fifteen sales, the middle one is 19 Georgica Woods Lane at $3,175,000. Without the Beach Lane house, the median of the remaining fourteen is about $3.09 million. One oceanfront estate doubles the average and moves the median by less than $100,000.
A buyer comparing hamlets should start here. Wainscott records only a handful of sales a year, and a single trophy sale can make a summary figure look like a different market. The median is the closer guide to typical prices, and the full deed list is closer still. A buyer can see the price of each sale and the street it sold on.
Sayre's Path shows the spread on a single road. Three Sayre's Path addresses closed in 2026. Number 95 sold for $2.25 million in January and number 179 for $3.01 million the same month. Number 176 sold for $9,095,000 in March. The top price on that road was about four times the lowest, a few months apart. Wainscott is priced lot by lot, and two houses on the same road can sell at very different prices.
For a broader view, Long Island Business News reported on October 8, 2026 that Miller Samuel's figures put Hamptons closings at 385 in the third quarter of 2026, down 8.6 percent from 421 in the same quarter of 2025. In that July-through-September quarter, the Hamptons single-family median was about $1.995 million, down roughly 5 percent from a year earlier. The single-family average was $3.18 million, down nearly 12 percent.
The Wainscott list runs January through October in one hamlet, and the LIBN figures cover one quarter across the Hamptons, so they give a position rather than a match. Wainscott's lowest 2026 closing, 4 South Breeze Drive at $1,475,000 in August, was below the Hamptons third-quarter median. Its middle sales, roughly $2.6 million to $3.6 million, were close to the Hamptons third-quarter average. A buyer whose budget is near the Hamptons average and who looks at Wainscott is looking at the center of this hamlet's market, not its lower end.
The most recent sale on the list is 89 Wainscott Main Street, which closed October 8 at $5.45 million, near the top of the hamlet's regular range. Thirteen of the fifteen 2026 closings fell between $1.475 million and $5.45 million, and those thirteen are the prices most Wainscott buyers will compare against.
Price is one thing a Wainscott buyer is weighing. The other is what the center of the hamlet will look like. A purchase now in contract will help decide that.
The site is the former Wainscott Sand & Gravel mine at 104 Wainscott Northwest Road, known locally as "the pit." It lies between Wainscott Northwest Road and Montauk Highway. The site was once planned as a 50-lot light-industrial complex called the Wainscott Commercial Center, 27east reported. It would be the third reclaimed sand mine the Town has bought, after land at the end of Navy Road in 2002 and on Fresh Pond Road in 2013, according to 27east.
East Hampton Town is now in contract to buy 38.3 acres of the 70.5-acre site for about $36 million, the East Hampton Star reported on November 12. Most of that land would become parks, recreation and open space. About five acres would be held for municipal uses the Town has not yet set. 27east reported that buildings from the old cement plant have been demolished and that leveling and seeding are underway, with the goal of returning the property to native meadow. "This is a large purchase, even for CPF," Town Land Management Director Scott Wilson said at the October 15 hearing, according to 27east.
The deal depends on $15 million in private money. The Friends of Georgica Pond Foundation and the Peconic Land Trust need to raise that amount by December 31. If they don't, the contract can be called off. At a Wainscott Citizens Advisory Committee meeting, Kim Quarty, executive director of the Friends of Georgica Pond Foundation, called the acquisition "a very rare opportunity to protect so much land in the Georgica Pond watershed." She also said, "We don't have the actual commitment yet of the $15 million," and explained that the groups are asking donors to sign pledges to be collected in 2027, the Star reported. According to 27east, Town officials would likely keep the right to go ahead without outside funding if the private money falls short.
Buyers should also know that the purchase doesn't cover the whole site. The Star reported that about 19 acres at the north end of the property are outside the purchase and remain privately held. If the deal closes, about half of the old mine becomes town land, mostly open space.
The site's location adds to its importance. Quarty said the headwaters of Georgica Pond are effectively across the street from the former mine, 27east reported. When this post is published, the December 31 deadline is about six weeks away. A buyer looking at Wainscott this winter should check the result after that date.
What was the lowest-priced Wainscott closing this year? Among the closings listed here, the lowest was 4 South Breeze Drive at $1,475,000 on August 21, and the next was 11 Oakwood Court at $1.6 million on August 24.
Is the $59 million Beach Lane sale a sign that Wainscott prices are rising? It is one sale of one oceanfront estate. Apart from it and 176 Sayre's Path, the thirteen other closings between January and October 2026 ranged from $1.475 million to $5.45 million. The median for 2026 stays near $3.1 million whether or not the Beach Lane house is counted.
If you are weighing Wainscott against East Hampton, Amagansett or Sagaponack, I'm glad to go through this year's deed list with you street by street. We can look at what sold near the house you're considering and how close it is to the pit. See our Wainscott neighborhood page, or if you own a home here, start with a home valuation. Let's Connect with Jeanne Hutson.
Stay up to date on the latest real estate trends.
November 19, 2026
November 12, 2026
November 5, 2026
October 29, 2026
October 22, 2026
October 15, 2026
A licensed Realtor® with extensive hometown knowledge of the East End villages and hamlets